|
Summary of Weekly
Review Articles
Valuation and Business Analysis |
|
To obtain
a copy of any of these articles click on the title to download the
newsletter edition containing the article. |
|
|
Resource Prices Never Lower
Long term investors
have great difficulty getting value from a resource investment. |
|
Investor Confidence: How Companies and Analysts Collude
Private investors,
unsuspectingly, have become the losers in the relationship between
companies and analysts. |
|
Employee Share Options: Too Quick to Judgement
The move to expense
employee share options is a knee-jerk reaction which fails to come to
terms with the fundamental problem. |
|
Weak Australian Corporate Profitability
The underlying
profitability of the Australian economy still seems inadequate for the
level of the Australian market. |
|
Economy Not Helping US Market (and vice versa)
Weakening US
manufacturing conditions are signaling further weakness in US equity
markets. |
|
Declining Commodity Prices: More Evidence
There is broad evidence
of a long-term decline in commodity values. |
|
Housing: Yes, There Will Be A Fall!
History says that the
housing market will weaken but not until interest rates begin to rise.
Could some of the more dire warnings of housing price falls come to pass?
The answer is ‘yes’. |
|
Required Returns: Investment v Speculation
Investors need to have
a clear view of their required rate of return to be able to make effective
investment decisions. Having a target or required rate of return
differentiates investment from speculation. |
|
Equity Valuation Guideposts
A stable or
appreciating Australian dollar could persuade overseas investors that the
risks from investing in the Australian market have diminished. The
prospect of the Australian market rising at a faster rate that the
underlying growth in profitability might become a realistic expectation. |
|
Growth and Returns: How the Companies Line Up
Equity market
valuations have become more reasonable but the growth expectations implied
by current prices are still likely to be testing. |
|
'Market Darlings' to 'Fallen Angels': How Investors Can Cope
Several pending
corporate restructures highlight how short-lived is the success of the
typical Australian listed company. This should be a genuine concern for
long-term equity investors because it affects adversely the overall
valuation accorded the Australian market. |
|
Beating The Expectations
Once information comes
to hand which changes views about the sustainable potential growth rate,
the higher the previous growth expectation the more dramatic will be the
price effect. |
|
Bond Yield Guideposts
Cyclically higher
inflation in the USA which would tend to drive rates higher would be
offset by a decline in the Australian yield premium as the relative
inflation performance converges. |
|
Vale: Australian Resource Investments
The foreshadowed merger
of MIM Holdings with Xstrata, a Swiss-based resources company, highlights
how the Australian resource major, like the dinosaur, has failed to cope
with its environment and is disappearing. |
|
Still Awaiting the e-commerce Revolution
The build-up in
e-commerce sales in the USA remains slow. |
|
Government Changes Forecasts
With prices now
expected to be increasing at a rate of 2½ to 3 percent and output growth
around three per cent, underlying profit growth could be expected to be 5½
to 6 per cent, substantially below the longer-term average. |
|
How
Can Hedging be Harmful?
The term ‘hedging’ has
been used misleadingly by companies to describe outright speculative
activities which add risks shareholders might never have envisaged. |
|
Australian Profit Update
There has been above
average profit growth reported for the September quarter. |
|
Asset Allocation Review
thebigpicture asset
allocation model suggests maintaining a relatively modest exposure to
domestic equities at the beginning of 2003 with cash levels remaining
relatively high.
|
|
A
Takeover: Then Comes The Real Decision
Investors should have
mixed feelings about a takeover bid for any of their shares. Takeovers
might induce higher share prices but, once completed, the investor must
choose alternative investments. |
|
Parking Funds: The Risk With Bonds
Investors using the bond
market as a safe harbour while awaiting a return to equities might be
incurring some additional risks. Cash might be the place to stay if
short-term equity risks are perceived to be too high. |
|
thebigpicture Themes Still Relevant
thebigpicture top ten
themes reflect the views of the author about some of the longer-term
trends which are affecting investment market outcomes. The themes,
originally published last year, have been reviewed with no changes. |
|
Gold Prices: Irrelevant But Fascinating
There is probably no
financial market indicator so widely reported and as irrelevant as the
gold price. Even so, it continues to fascinate. |
|
Restructuring: Another Company Falters
There was yet another
example in the past week of a company unable to cope with the aftermath of
its own bold strategy. This time it was Southcorp. There is a bigger
picture behind the demise of its chief executive. |
|
High Growth Stocks: The Risk Revealed
The beginning of the
half-year reporting season has immediately highlighted the riskiness
attaching to companies whose share prices imply high growth rates. |
|
Share Repurchases: The Safest Investments
With lower share prices
extending across the market, companies will begin to consider more
actively the possibility of buying back their own shares. |
|
Dividends: The New Emphasis on Income
The fall in Australian
share prices (and apparent absence of prospective capital gains) has
placed more emphasis on dividend yield as a guidepost for stock choice.
Dividends are now approaching the yield available to investors from
government bonds. |
|
Whither Internet Retailing?
Use of the internet for
retail transactions is growing but, having started from nothing, it is
still far from making a meaningful contribution to commercial activity. |
|
Housing: The Price Cycle Continues
The Australian housing
cycle is an unintended beneficiary of Iraq failing to disarm. |
|
Equities: The Value Gap Closes
Relatively resilient
corporate profits and a weaker equity market are achieving the adjustment
which was necessary to realign equity values. |
|
e-Commerce: Dominated by B2B
e-commerce has been
adopted far more widely for transactions between businesses than by
consumers seeking to purchase goods or services. The extent of the
difference has again been highlighted by some recent statistics from the
US Census Bureau. |
|
The
Very Big Picture
The events in the middle
East might have obscured how long term trends underlie many of the
economic and political developments which affect investment markets. |
|
thebigpicture Investment Decision Model
Now that the Iraqi war
is all but over, investors might be tempted back to equity markets. To
avoid the risks of irrational exuberance they will need some valuation
guideposts. |
|
The
Shrinking Australian Market
Pan Pharmaceuticals, MIM
Holdings, OPSM, AMP and Neverfail: more companies which have either fallen
from grace or which seem destined to be put out of the reach of Australian
investors. |
|
The
Australian Market Shrinks….Again
The destruction of value
at AMP, once one of Australia’s leading financial institutions, throws up
further questions about the Australian continuous disclosure regime. It
also highlights that strategic failure, once evident, is not easily
rectified. And, of course, it is yet another example of Australia’s
golden rule of corporate behaviour: when in doubt, restructure! |
|
Using Debt: It May Be Too Late
Recourse to debt funded
education significantly changes the balance of individual finances. A
higher debt tolerance might reflect the peculiar experience of those
currently making policy. It might be inappropriate for a subsequent
generation. |
|
Getting Used To A Higher Dollar
Economic conditions
justify a more buoyant Australian dollar. However, the world economy has
a vested interest in a strong US dollar and, longer term, upward pressure
on its value could well resume. For investors, the stronger Australian
dollar is beneficial because it makes Australia a less risky destination
for offshore capital. |
|
The
Profit Risk
Recognition that profit
sensitivity to exchange rate movements will be affected by how a company
organizes its production and sales activities is necessary for effective
risk management. |
|
Conspirators or Markets?
Are copper miners conspiring or simply
doing what the market requires?
|
|
The
ASX: Improving US$ Returns
The stronger Australian
dollar should provide a fillip to the Australian equity market. Overseas
investors will see that some of the risk from investing in Australian
equities has been taken away. |
|
e-Commerce:
The Christmas Effect
The latest report by the
US Department of Commerce on the uptake by consumers of e-commerce has
shown that there has been little progress. |
|
Housing: Too Protected?
In Australia, the
housing market exerts a strong influence on monetary policy. It might be
time for housing to lose its privileged position and stop disadvantaging
other parts of the economy. |
|
Inflation For Investors
Four times a year we are
told what Australia’s inflation rate has been in the prior quarter. What
should investors be looking for when they pore over these numbers? |
|
Setting Standards: Accounting v Value
Australia’s accounting
standards do not measure up according to an international accounting
expert. Australian equity investments risked being ostracized. But do
accountants really know what constitutes value? That is the key issue
for an investor trying
to judge the debate. |
|
Biotechs: Boom Or Malaise?
With around 80 companies
listed on the Australian stock market making a bid for medical history,
investor excitement should be running high. However, the experience of
Australian biotech companies is a sobering mixture of failure,
disappointed promise and, at best, modest accomplishment.
|
|
No
More Earnings Surprises ?
Companies, not analysts,
are now responsible for profit forecasts. This is one of the significant
changes to occur as the reporting and disclosure regime has evolved in
recent years.
|
|
Another Fad: Lose The Property
An emerging fad among
companies is to separate property assets from operating businesses. Does
this make sense for shareholders? What are the guideposts which investors
should apply in deciding whether restructuring in this way adds to the
value of the company? |
|
Metal Prices: Some Things Don’t Change
Higher metal prices are
a respite for mining companies but no escape from the long-term pressures
dogging the industry. For some, rising prices are also a sign that the
international economy is about to turn for the better. This interpretation
of what is happening might be too optimistic. |
|
Older And Less Profitable
An aging population and
slowing economic growth could halve the rate of company profit growth. |
|
Info-Tech Companies: Signs Of Life
Prices of information
technology stocks have been rising. Demand for their products and their
services has been strengthening. thebigpicture highlights a way of
measuring the improvement in conditions. |
|
Corporate Returns: Working Assets Harder
Improved financial
returns from Australian listed companies have come from working existing
assets harder. Business expansion has not been important. And, despite
some improvement in returns, larger industrial companies are barely adding
value for shareholders. |
|
Company Growth Expectation Lowered
The stock market has
been downgrading the growth prospects of Australia’s larger companies.
That is probably good: the overall outlook is now more realistic when
viewed against potential business conditions.
|
|
Company Growth Expectations
Measured against the
growth prospects of the Australian economy, overall growth rates expected
for larger Australian companies are now more sustainable. The disparity
among companies’ growth prospects remains high with investors
needing to make choices
about management capacity to deliver. |
|
Free Trade: What’s In It For Investors?
With the Australian
economy having been opened to more competition over the last two decades
and Australia's corporate regulatory regime progressively harmonised with
that of the USA, the impact here of a trade agreement is likely to be
quite limited. |
|
The
Angels Keep Falling
One of the most
perplexing challenges for an Australian equity investor is dealing with
the propensity for self inflicted wounds among Australian companies. The
frequent conversion of market icons to fallen angels damages the standing
of the Australian equity market and complicates investment decision
making. |
|
International Equities
More Attractive
thebigpicture half yearly review of market conditions
shows a macro environment more favourable for international equities.
International equity market conditions will help support the Australian
market but domestic profit momentum will be constrained by monetary policy
changes. |
|
Fed
v RBA: Who’s Right?
There is a difference
between the US Federal Reserve Board and the Australian Reserve Bank in
the conduct of economic policy. The Fed seems more investor friendly than
the RBA. |
|
Free Trade? Not Really
The Australian government has done a market access deal with the US
administration. The US has conceded on matters which are not important to
it. The Australian side has conceded on some of its priorities. Free trade
it is not.
|
|
IPO’s: Track Records Count Most
IPO’s may be an overrated investment opportunity. Changing pricing
arrangements are making them less attractive. Now, research from the USA
shows up a need for investors to be very choosy: a company’s history says
a lot about its post-IPO risk of failure.
|
|
Private Equity: More To Come?
Big gains are being realised by private equity investors as they sell some
of their holdings through public listings. Many of the high profile
transactions are not repeatable. Returns reflect additional risk and are
likely to decline.
|
|
What Is Shareholder Value?
Shareholder value is a term bandied around investment markets by companies
and investors without a lot of agreement about its meaning. There is a
clear-cut definition which investors should bear in mind when making their
decisions.
|
|
Value: Growth v Inflation
The good news in the USA about its economic performance has prompted some
selling of equities. This seemingly perverse reaction illustrates the
trade-off between growth and inflation.
|
|
International Investment: How Much?
Fund managers encourage people to invest in international equities. The
argument that they are going to be better off if they go offshore is an
enticing one but is not as clear-cut as the marketers suggest.
|
|
P/E’s: Easy But Useless?
The p/e is widely used as an investment decision making tool but it is not
the simple valuation indicator many pretend. It can be very useful in
some very limited circumstances. Under most other conditions, its
usefulness is limited.
|
|
US Elections: Adding Value
The US electoral cycle does have an effect on equity markets. Returns are
more likely to be positive and above average in 2004 because a
presidential election is due in November.
|
|
Commodity Prices: ‘The Quick and the Dead’
High commodity prices have raised expectations about the performance of
resource sector equities. However, some forecasters are expecting
commodity prices to weaken in the 12 months ahead. This is the riskiest
part of the cycle for equity investors despite company earnings looking so
buoyant.
|
|
Australian Elections: The Market Wins
As in the USA, the Australian electoral cycle does appear to affect equity
prices. Elections are good. The aftermath is not.
|
|
It’s My Value Chain
Control of the value chain is an important indicator of business
sustainability.
|
|
Financial Reporting: What
To Look For
Deciding what to look for in the mountain of information which comes with
the annual reporting season is a challenge for an investor. Here are some
guideposts to help take the value investor to the peak and back safely.
|
|
Commodity Price Strategies
BHP Billiton (BHP) has made it clear that, in acting to maximise its own
value, it is likely to put downward pressure on commodity prices.
|
|
Accounting Standards: Benefits Questioned
Companies are presently channelling more resources into their accounting
functions to make their public reporting conform to international
accounting standards. This is to make them more attractive to offshore
investors. However, investors want more than a change in accounting
practices.
|
|
Profits Deliver Valuation
Boost
Accelerating profit
growth in the June quarter makes Australian stock market valuations more
attractive. |
|
Company Results: Returns
Up
Australia's larger listed companies significantly improved their financial
performance in the past year. They continued their relatively conservative
approach, relying more on better use of existing assets than expansion of
their asset bases to boost results.
|
|
Equity Return Analysis
Looking at value from the perspective of the return on equity also
highlights how managers have been working to get more from physical assets
but have been reluctant to use gearing aggressively to add value.
|
|
Share Buybacks: Sell &
Win; Stay & Lose?
Share buybacks are not what they were originally intended. Amidst the
current share buyback fad, there might be as many benefits for a departing
shareholder as one remaining.
|
|
Share Buybacks: Where Is
The Value?
A company can raise its equity market value by widening the spread between
its return on funds and its cost of capital. This is the underpinning for
a share buyback.
|
|
Stock Picking Might Never
Be Easier
There should be little excuse for active fund managers failing to beat the
market in the last quarter. Unless a fund manager had a manic attachment
to the banking sector, stock selection should have been relatively
straightforward and rewarding.
|
|
Midcaps Raise The
Standard
The improvement in the financial performance of Australia’s smaller
companies has been a feature of the Australian market in the past year.
|
|
Banks: Not ‘Which’ But
‘How Much’
In making a bank investment, an investor needs to make a stock selection
and an asset allocation decision.
|
|
Yes, You Can Learn
Individuals do learn from their investing experiences.
|
|
Midcaps: Margins Deliver
Value
The sharp improvement in the financial performance of Australia’s smaller
companies, driven by margin improvement, has made these companies more
secure investments.
|
|
Exchange Rates: What To
Do?
As the Australian economy has become more sophisticated, the winners and
losers from an exchange rate appreciation are harder to fathom.
|
Telstra has hit the headlines again as it fights to extricate itself from
a web of poor governance practices, structural failings and populist
policy making. The bigger picture is that its behaviour will have an
impact on how people around the world judge the Australian market.
|
Amcor’s position in the industrial value chain might have had something to
do with its recently disclosed trade practices predicament.
|
National Foods showed that there is a different way of handling an
unwanted takeover bid. But it requires directors to be confident about
the value of their company. Few appear to be.
|